Iron from space in Quran.

Iron from space in quran?

Introduction

Some Muslim apologetics claim that Quran mentioned 1400 years ago that iron came from space. But they have never analysed thier claims and why there claim is true, here I am going to respond to these apologetics like Zakir naik and so called Osama Abdullah.

Refutation of iron from space in quran 

First of all I am going to ask two questions:
1. Why should we think that Quran mentions iron was literally sent down rather than it's from god.
2. Where did iron came from? Heaven, god, alien's? from where?
A1. Now some Muslims apologetics will claim that it came from space and they will use this claim " When you say car came it came by driving and hence quran mentions iron from space because sent down will obviously mean literally sent down" this is an extremely stupid claim they don't even know that when people use sent down they have different meanings like revelation and literally sent down and car came by driving is obvious any person would know but when you say sent down they have different meanings and it isn't obvious that iron came from space just because you live in 21st century and it's obvious to you that iron came from space doesn't mean people at 7th century mean sent down.If you assume that it reffers to sent down as literally then why? as I mentioned above words are used in different times include different meanings so it's nonsensical to mention that they mean that it came from space just because it's obvious to you that iron came from space.
Now someone will say " Isn't it obvious that when people say rain came down it would mean it's from clouds? And if it does then why not sent down as literally sent down?" Now the problem with this claim is that rain came down is an observable phenomenon while iron coming down isn't observable why assume that it reffers to literally sent down rather than from God?
 Different words have different meanings at different times and situations so there is no reason to think that they meant it was literally sent down from outer space when they say it was sent down.
                                                     

Popular posts from this blog

Responding to Logan about existence of god.

Image
So, he tells that anything that exists has a potential to exist, and there must be an action that turn this potential to actual being if there was nothing to act then there would be nothing only what could have happened this means that there must be a first actor. But this is false because a thing can be in eternal motion (moving eternally) and still create the universe,  Example: Thing A and B exists eternally. They are in eternal motion and doesn't need any external force to do that and they are in a space that is like a spehere. Since they are in eternal motion they must combine. If they did hence forming a thing that can create the universe. And remember the rarity of these things combining is 40% means that these two combining is rare doesn't mean it can't happen just means that it will take time to happen like 10⁹⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰⁰ years later also the property of A is to gather information and perform work like a machine and B has the information about how a world ca...
Read more